Brown Fat vs. White Fat

When I first started on this journey to conquer the English Channel, people emphasized two things to me:

  1. Cold exposure:  I needed to spend a lot of time in cold water so that I would “get used to it”
  2. Weight gain:  Nearly everyone who found out I wanted to swim the Channel would look me over and say, “you’re gonna have to put on some weight!”

This raised some issues in my head.  To address the second point, intentionally gaining weight for an athletic endeavor seems unhealthy to me.  To address the first, what does “getting used to it” actually mean?  It can’t just be a mental thing that allows your body to adapt to spending hours on end in cold water.  There had to be some corresponding physiological change that allowed the  body to tolerate cold better.

Brown Fat vs. White Fat

The Difference Between a White Fat Cell (fat storage) and a Brown Fat Cell (heat factory)

One possibility people have raised is the existence of brown fat.  Unlike white fat, which is found under the skin, deposits of brown fat are present around vital internal organs and along the back and sternum.  Further, brown fat has mitochontria:  it is metabolically active.  White fat is not.  This means that brown fat is capable of generating ATP.  Or, more simply, brown fat generates heat.

The only problem with this theory is that brown fat was only thought to be present in infants.  No one had ever detected brown fat in adults.  However, in the April publication of the New England Journal of Medicine, not one, but THREE independent labs proved the existence of brown fat in adults.  Further, using different experiments, all three groups demonstrated that prolonged exposure to cold resulted in an increase in an adult’s amount of brown fat.

Summary:  brown fat generates heat.  Exposure to cold increases an individual’s brown fat.  More brown fat = more heat = you can stay warmer in cold longer.

Beautiful.

Going back to the two points: point 1 addresses the way to increase brown fat, while point 2 addresses the way to increase white fat.

Sure, white fat can provide *some* increased insulation.  But brown fat not only insulates the core (the most important part of the body to keep warm), it also acts as a heat factory.  Hence the way you can “get used to” the cold.

Here’s an even cooler implication of this discovery:  you can train for the Channel even when you aren’t actually swimming!  Any time you expose your body to the cold, you are helping your body produce more brown fat, thereby increasing your cold tolerance.

In light of these publications, I’m finally taking the advice of my friend:  I’m now going around with bare legs and flip-flops, whether rain, shine, wind, whatever, intentionally exposing myself to being cold to increase my brown fat stores.  In my opinion, it’s a more healthy approach to cold water swimming, though it earns me some funny looks when I’m sporting a skirt and Rainbows in the arctic South San Francisco winds.

For the abstracts of these super cool papers, see below:

Identification and Importance of Brown Adipose Tissue in Adult Humans

Functional Brown Adipose Tissue in Healthy Adults

Cold-Activated Brown Adipose Tissue in Healthy Men


3 Responses to “Brown Fat vs. White Fat”

  • Larry Weisenthal Says:

    Brown fat is fascinating. We are talking about tiny quantities, at most only a couple of ounces (60 grams), distributed primarily in the back and neck areas. But not only can it keep you warm, it may improve glucose and lipid metabolism and also be useful in obesity prevention and treatment. I’ve personally been looking for opportunities to enjoy a little cold exposure, e.g. wearing only a T shirt while attending an outdoor sporting event on a cool and windy day, eschewing a sweat shirt or fleece while sitting in a cold room, and so on. I’m going to try to see what effect, if any, this has on my weight, blood pressure, and cold water swimming tolerance.

  • Steven Munatones Says:

    There are several of us in the contemporary open water world who have always believed in this brown fat. This belief goes back all the way to Duke Nelson, a famous marathon swimmer of the 1930s. We have never advocated or advised ANYONE to gain weight for a marathon swim, so I believe you are absolutely correct in your approach.

  • LeeAnn Says:

    I guess those cold winters in Cambridge were useful after all :)

Leave a Reply